Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 75

"We're here!" Mom called as we walked through the front door of the beach house.

I tried to book it through the house to find my boyfriends, but Dad kept a tight grip on my shoulder. I stomped my foot, and crossed my arms. If I'm going to be treated like a child, then I'm going to act like one. "You are not leaving my sight." Dad told me.

I scowled at nothing.

"David, will you just let her go." Mom said as we walked through the house.

"Finally, you're all here!" Sarah said once we made it to the back porch.

My eyes instantly connected with my four favorites. I smiled brightly, and once again, tried to rush to them. Only to be pulled back.

"Dad! I will be right there." I said pointing to the table." Caleb is with his girlfriend." I complained.

"She has a point David." Darla agreed with me. "You shouldn't treat them differently according to their genders. That will do no good for their mental health." She said.

Dad turned his head to all of them. Darla, and Jen smirked. Ally averted her eyes. Sarah just shook her head amused. All of the men refused to acknowledge my dad. "Did.. Did all of you know about the relationship our kids share?" Dad asked.

Oh no.

"Well, we knew that our son's perferred this lifestyle before we moved here." Jen said.

"And it was extremely obvious from the beginning that something was going on with them all." Sarah added.

"And you let them all keep hanging out? Knowing they have been dating?" Dad asked.

Mom put her hand on Dad's arm.

"Honey, relax." She said.

"They're all pretty much adults. Besides, I know our sons are good guys. And Millie is a wonderful girl." Sarah said.

"Plus, it's much more healthy of a relationship than you'd think. Come, I can tell you all about it." Darla said.

She looped her arm through Dad's, and drug him away. I took the opportunity to book it to my guys. I sat at the table between Atlas, and Leo, the two biggest guys. "Missed us already princess." Leo teased.

These two were just with me last night. They all know everything now. I'm still freaking out about everything.

"Dad is really angry." Caleb said with a snort.

Lila elbowed him in the gut.

"It's okay Mil, Jen was furious when she first found out, and now look at her." Lila told me.

"Did any of your dads react this way?" I asked.

"Our dad told Lila she wasn't allowed to have a relationship like this." Leo told me.

I frowned.

"Mine refused to talk to me about it." Oliver said. "Say's he'd rather stay ignorant, but hopes I'm happy."

I rolled my eyes, at least that's better.

"My dad made tons of jokes at first." Atlas said. "He was more supportive than Mom, at first anyways. Something about, let the kid be happy." He said with a laugh.

"I don't think your dad cares about any other realtionship other than his own." Lila said with a laugh.

"Yeah, your dad is obessed with your mom." Milo added.

Atlas wrapped an arm around my shoulders, and pulled me to him.

"I see where you get it from now." I mumbled.

"Well, my dad was very supportive as well." Milo said. "Dad doesn't talk a whole lot. He's not really a... feelings type of guy if you haven't notied." Milo said with a laugh. "He actually sat down to ask me a bunch of genuine questions. I'm not sure if that is due to Mom, but it was really nice to have two supportive parents." He said.

I blew out a breath. "I wish my dad would at least calm down." I said.

Caleb snorted. "Fat chance." He said.

"So, what happened?" Lila asked. "We didn't get to hear about it." She said gesturing between her and Caleb.

I sighed. "It went exactly how I thought it would go."

"That bad?" Caleb asked.

"Well, I actually came clean about the bullying. That wasn't planned, but I'm glad I did it." I started.

"I am too Mil." Caleb said.

"They were very angry about the bullying at school, and the principal not doing anything about it. Mom cried a little bit for not paying more attention to me. It was awful." I said.

Leo rested a hand on my thigh under the table, and gave me a reassuring squeeze. Atlas wrapped his arm around my wasit, and kissed the top of my head. I shook my head, and continued.

"Then I told them about James, then about the guys. Dad flipped his shit. Then Mom yelled at him. Like really yelled." I said.

"No way?" Caleb said.

I nodded. "Dad acted exactly like I knew he would. Totally flipped out, and banned me from seeing any of you ever again." I rolled my eyes.

"Yet, here you are." Lila said.

"Yeah, cause Mom flipped her shit on him. I knew that she would be supportive, but I didn't expect her to act that way. Mom never raises her voice. Even when we were kids she barely yelled." I said.

"I'm glad she's on your side." Lila said.

"What did she say to Dad?" Caleb asked.

"Well, she told Dad that he can't boss me around because I'm 18. She also him that they raised me to be able to make my own decisions, and knowing me, I most likely didn't make a decision like this lightly." I said. Milo snorted. "That's f*****g true."

I narrowed my eyes at him. "How about you just shut up."

Milo looked up at me with amusement dancing in his eyes. He made the action to zip his lips, and lock it. Then he winked at me.

I rolled my eyes.

"Anyways, she said that they were much worse when they were my age, which I find hard to believe." I said.

"I don't." Leo said.

I turned my head to him. "You barely even know my parents." I said.

Leo smirked, and looked at Lila. I followed his eyes to my best friend. Lila refused to meet mine, or Caleb's eyes.

"What are you hiding from me baby?" Caleb asked her.

"Uh, well, we might have overheard our parents talking a few nights ago... About something... extremely disgusting." She said awkwardly.

"So disgusting that Lila burst into the room to demand answers." Leo said amused. "It was gross though. Something I could have lived my whole life without knowing"

"And what's that?" I asked.

"Well," Lila started. "They were arguing in their room, which lead us to listen. Our parents never fight. Apparently, Leo told Mom about his new girlfriend." Lila gave Leo a pointed look.

"At first we didn't understand why they were arguing. They didn't when Leo dated.." Lila cleared her throat. "Anyways, after I heard something about... sleeping with... uhm..."

Caleb and I raised a brow at Lila. She is really struggling to spit it out. Poor girl.

"Apparently, our parents used to do some freaky shit together." Leo said.

My eyes went wide.

"Like, share each other freaky." He said.

"No shit." Milo breathed out.

"That's... interesting." Oliver added.

"They don't anymore though... right?" Caleb asked Leo.

My eyes also snapped up to Leo. That would be so weird if they are. Our parents, and then us too... Oh god no.

Leo shook his head, and laughed.

"No, I mean, I don't think so. From what they said, it was a college thing." He said.

"But they haven't seen each other in so long.." I trailed off.

Caleb shook his head. "Shut up Millie."

"I hope none of our parents joined." Atlas said.

"Pft." Lila spewed. "Like your dad would ever share your mother. He is obessed with her." She said.

Atlas beamed, and squeezed me tighter to him.

"I understand how he feels now." He said making me blush.

"Alright, so what about the stuff with James?" Lila asked.

I sighed. "I'm too drained for this." I grumbled.

"You don't have to talk about it if you don't want." Lila offered.

"No, it's okay." I said.

"I'll be right back." Oliver said.

He stood up, and came to kiss the top of my head. Then he disappeared into the house.

"Well, they are pissed." I started.

"Rightfully so." Lila commented.

"Dad says there is no way James is going to get away with it though. He is determined to take this to court, and win. We are filing a police report tomorrow." I told them. "Good." Caleb said.

I nodded.

"Mom was nearly distraut. I think this was one of her worst fears when having a daughter. She wouldn't stop crying. It was a giant mess." I said.

Lila gave me a soft smile.

"It's going to be okay from here on out. Court is going to be rough, but the worst is over for now." She said reassuringly.

I smiled back to her. Then a plate of food was set down in front of me. Complete joy spread throughout me.

I looked up to see Oliver smiling down at me. He pushed up his glasses, and kissed my cheek.

"I thought the food wasn't ready yet." I said.

"This is just a snack for my angel." Oliver said as he took his seat back.

"And we all know how hungry you get." Atlas teased.

"Jealous again I see." I teased back.

Atlas laughed. "I'm jealous of anything that goes into that pretty mouth of yours. Unless it's my c-"

"Okay!" Caleb said. "Not around me."

"Caleb, maybe you should talk with your dad." Lila suggested.

"About what?" Caleb asked.

Lila and I shared a bored look. Caleb can be a f*****g idiot sometimes.

"The guys came clean with you about their intentions with your sister. You reacted.... well. Maybe you can talk to your dad about it." She suggested.

Caleb looked at me, and then back to Lila. He huffed out some hollow laughter as he stared down at her.

"You... want me.. to talk to my dad... about my sister... his little's girl's... s*x life?" Caleb asked.

"Oh my god. Why does it just have to be about that?" I asked frustrated.

"None of you need to know what happens between us in the bedroom. All you need to do is tell Dad that I'm happy, and that they all treat me right." I said annoyed.

Caleb's eyes snapped to mine.

"Are you crazy?" He asked.

"I'm getting there." I mumbled.

Goddamn, I'm thristy.

Just as the thought hit me, a bottle of water was set down in front of me. I looked up to see Milo staring down at me. I didn't even see him leave.

I frowned at him. "How did you know I was thirsty?" I asked.

Milo chuckled, and brought his lips to my ear.

"You're always thirsty baby. You prove that anytime I sneak into your bedroom at night." He whispered.

I blushed, and swatted his face away from me.

Milo isn't lying. Especially after finally having each of them. I can never keep my hands to myself. The roles have almost been reversed with how much I touch them. I'm constantly looking for an excuse to get physical with them. Leo is always telling me to chill, or to not to. We have this to do, or that to do. Or, it's always, you're being too loud. Or, no I can't use that right now princess, it's too loud.

Fucking irritating.

What do I have to do to get spanked around here?

I nearly choked on my water at the thought. Oh my god, Milo is right. I'm thirsty as hell.

Is there something wrong with me? Am I a nympho?

"Stop thinking so hard about it princess. There is nothing wrong with you." Leo whispered in my ear.

I turned my head to frown at him.

"How do you always know what I'm thinking?" I accused.

Leo smirked down at me. "Because I pay attention.

What does that mean?

I wanted to ask, but before I could...

"Ahem."

We all turned to look up at my dad.

Oh no.

"I want to speak with my daughter's boyfriend. All four of you, in private. Now."