Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 49

Oliver's words had a shiver running through me. I bobbed myself on his c**k, and his hand quickly made it's way back to my hair. Oliver started to move my head for me. It's honestly super hot.

I wasn't sure if Atlas was even going to join us at this point, so I just kept sucking on Oliver. If Atlas just wants to watch then fine, but I am still getting f****d tonight. I know that Oliver will gladly give me what I want.

Suddenly, hands were gripping my waist. The position I'm in has me on top of Oliver with my a*s in the air. Oliver moved back on the bed more, and I followed with him to keep him in my mouth. All this did was give Atlas better access behind me. I smiled around Oliver's c**k when he looked down at me.

Atlas's hands slowly moved up the sides of my thighs. They moved over the curve of my a*s. I looked up to see Oliver staring at Atlas, probably watching his hands as the roam my a*s. Atlas grabbed my hips, and pushed himself into me. Even through his jeans I can feel his hard c**k. I moaned, and pushed my a*s against him more.

"Is she wet Atlas?" Oliver asked.

Atlas let out a shaky breath before he slowly slid my thong down to my knees. Then he pushed his fingers through my wet folds. I could practically feel his body slump.

"Holy shit, she's f*****g soaked." He said.

"Good, maybe you should take this top off. It snaps in the back like a bra right?" Oliver suggested.

Atlas used his hand that was not inside of me to reach up and unhook my top. Oliver must be way more observant than I thought. I leaned up on my knees so that Atlas could slide my straps off my arms. I looked up at him as he did so. He looks so mezmorized. Atlas gripped my chin. Just when I thought he was going to lean down and kiss me, he pushed my mouth back to Oliver. I wrapped my lips around Oliver's head, and then took his entire length. Oliver moaned as he moved his hand back to my hair. Atlas brought my ass back in the air. He pushed his fingers back to my pussy before dipping two fingers inside of me. I moaned loudly around Oliver's cock.

"She looks ready to me Atlas." Oliver said, and I started to bob my head on him faster.

"She's so wet." Atlas moaned out.

"Give it to her Atlas. You know she wants your big cock in her." Oliver said.

"But..." He trailed off.

Oliver's eyes flickered down to me. There was a hint in his hazel eyes. I let go of his cock with a pop, and turned to look at Atlas. Then I gave him my best innocent look.

"You don't want to f**k me Atlas?" I said sadly.

Atlas shivered. "It's not that baby. I really really, really do. It's just..."

"Just what?" I asked. "It's okay if you don't want to. I just wanted to make your birthday special. I thought that maybe if I gave you myself that you would know how much you mean to me." I said. It wasn't a total lie. This may have been Leo's idea, but I did hope that by doing it Atlas would know how much I care about him.

"Come on Atlas. You're making our girl think you don't want her." Oliver said.

"But.." Atlas said.

Oliver sighed. "You want to lose to Leo, or make our girl feel so f*****g good. Make her creame all over that fat cock of yours. I bet she could even take us both tonight." He said.

My eyes went wide and I turned back to Oliver. "Both?" I asked.

Oliver nodded. "That's right. You ever done anal?" He asked, and I shook my head. "I bet I could get that a*s of yours ready."

I gulped.

"Would you like that babygirl?" Atlas asked.

I looked up at him. "H-how do I get ready?" I asked.

Atlas smiled. "You just keep sucking on Oliver. Let me play with you for a bit." He said.

I turned back to Oliver, and didn't hesitate to take in his cock. I never knew I liked giving head this much. It was never like this with James. Never this fun.

Atlas dipped his fingers back into my pussy. I moaned, and pushed against them. Damn, it feels so good. Atlas began pumping his fingers in and out of me. I could barely focus on sucking Oliver. I'm pretty much just moaning with his cock in my mouth. If it wasn't for his hand on my hair I wound't be moving at all. "Alright babygirl, you let me know if this gets to be too much." Atlas said.

Before I could ask what he meant I felt him push inside my forbidden hole. I gasped around Oliver's c**k, which he apparently liked. Atlas pushed his finger all the way inside of me slowly. My eyes squeezed shut. "Fuuuuuucccckkkk." Atlas moaned behind me.

Atlas started to move his finger in and out. It hurt for a total of five seconds. Then I started to push back against him. Atlas chuckled, and then added another finger. That also hurt, for just a few seconds.

Honestly, it feels so good. I thought that it was supposed to hurt for way longer. Is it weird that I like it? Or does that mean that I'm perfect for this, for them?

Atlas had added another finger, and was now pumping in and out of me faster. I could feel my juices dripping down my thighs. If I would have known it was going to feel that good I might have asked them to do it sooner. "She's so fucking wet, all I needed was her juices to lube her up." Atlas said.

"I think maybe you should lay down, and let her ride you for a bit." Oliver suggested. "You're on the pill right angel?" He asked, and I nodded.

I moaned loudly. Oliver chuckled at me. Atlas removed himself before laying on the bed next to Oliver. I didn't hesitate at all to crawl on top of him. I pressed my lips to his in a frenzy. Apparently, having my a*s played with took me to a whole new level of horny. "Hmmm, so she likes her a*s being played with. That's my angel." Oliver said.

I rubbed my sopping pussy all over Atlas's hard cock. Atlas is gripping my hips, helping me move along him. All of our moans are bouncing off the walls. I feel like my entire body is on fire.

I pulled away panting. "I need you Atlas." I moaned out as I sat up, and lined myself on top of him. All I have to do is sit. "Tell me you want this too. Please." I begged.

Atlas shivered under me. His grip on my hips tightened. I'm so horny I feel like I could cry.

"I want you Millie. Always. You and only you." He said, and then pulled me down in one swift motion.

Atlas forced me to take in his entire length all at once. I gasped loudly, and winced slightly, but damn it feels f*****g amazing. My body shuttered, and I started to rock my hips. "Fuuuuuck babygirl. Your pussy feels fucking amazing." Atlas told me as he bounced me on his d**k.

"Atlas." I moaned out.

It was no shock to me that Atlas is huge. I've seen him naked a lot, even had his d**k in my mouth. I knew that it was going to hurt to have him inside of me. But it didn't. Maybe for a split second. Am I that worked up that I couldn't even feel the pain?

I leaned down, and pressed my lips to his as I rocked my hips. Then I sat all the way up. I'm not sure what came over me. I've never ridden anyone this way. It was like the guys evoked a certain kind of confidence in me.

"Holy fucking shit angel." Oliver whispered. "Look at you ride him. I told you you'd love it." He said, and I whimpered. "What about you Atlas? You look like you're in pure heaven."

"She... feels so fucking good." Atlas replied as he bounced me on his c**k again. "Like... this is unreal. Am I dreaming?"

Oliver chuckled. "Lean down angel. I need to be a part of this."

I leaned down, pressing my lips to Atlas's. I felt Olivers fingers move between us. Atlas jolted slightly, and squeezed my hips tighter. I moaned into his mouth. Oliver moved his fingers to my a*s hole. I pushed against Oliver, and then ground myself on Atlas. "Fuck, you're so ready. You want me baby? Can I be with you two?" Oliver asked.

I whimpered. "Yes. Please." I begged.

"I'll go slow angel, at first." Oliver said.

I felt his tip at my hole. A shutter ran through my body. Atlas kept my hips rolling. Then I felt Oliver push into me. My body went rigid. This was so much bigger than a few fingers.

"Relax angel, you gotta stay relaxed." Oliver cooed.

"Just look at me. Think about how good it feels to have me inside of you. And f**k does it feel good." Atlas said with a moan.

I looked at him, and focused on the plessure he is giving me. Taking a deep breath, I relaxed into him. I started to kiss his chest. Oliver pushed more into me. I winced, but tried to keep myself relaxed. A minute later, Oliver is all the way inside of me. I held my breath as I tried to get used to the feeling. Everything went still.

"Fuuuckkk. Holy fuck. She's so fucking tight. Holy shit Millie." Oliver moaned out.

"Breathe babygirl." Atlas told me.

My eyes popped open to see my favorite lopsided smile. I smiled back at him as I let my breath out. Then my body slumped against him.

"I'm gonna start moving angel. It's going to hurt, but it'll get better, just like with our fingers." Oliver said. "Okay." I whispered.

Atlas started to roll my hips, and I felt Oliver start to move. Oliver was right. A few seconds later, and all the pain is gone. Plessure was starting to build in me again. After another minute I started to move with them. It wasn't enough though, I needed more. "F-faster." I whimpered.

"You want more angel?" Oliver asked.

"Yes. Please." I begged.

Atlas shuttered. "If we go faster we aren't going to last long." He warned.

"Then we can go again." I said as I pressed my lips to his neck.

"Fuck." Atlas whispered.

Oliver gripped onto me. When I asked for more, he knew exactly what I needed. Oliver moved in and out of me so fast, and with so much force, that all Atlas and I could do was moan. I've never felt this full in my entire life. Just having Atlas was a lot, but this. I like it so much. No, I love it. I f*****g love it.

"Holy f*****g shit Millie." Oliver moaned out. He grabbed a fistfull of my hair, and pulled me back. The slight change in position had me and Atlas moaning louder. "You feel so fucking good. So fucking good. I will never ever leave you alone after this. You belong to us, and this ass is forever mine." He told me as he got faster and faster.

"Oliver.." I moaned out.

My orgasm is building higher and higher.

"Just think about all the fun things we can all do together. I can't wait for all of us to fucking have you. You'd like that wouldn't you Millie? You want all of us to fuck you senseless like this don't you?" Oliver was demanding an answer. "Yes! Yes! Oh my god yes! Oliver! Atlas!" I moaned out as my orgasm wracked my body.

Atlas's grip tightened on me. "Oh fuck. Her pussy... damnit.. I... Fuck! Millie fuck!" He moaned out, and I felt his cum coat my pussy.

Why does that turn my on even more?

Oliver grunted behind me. "I'm gonna fill you up with us baby." He said before giving me one last thrust.

I felt Oliver's cum drip down me and mix with Atlas's. Already I want them to keep f*****g me. It feels so good, to feel this full. I pushed back when Oliver started to slip out of me. Oliver chuckled. "You need some water angel. Then we can keep going." He said, and then pulled out of me.

Atlas had to lift me off of him. Apparently I'm more out of it than I thought I was. Atlas laid me on his bed, and tucked me under the covers. I squeezed my legs together.

"I'll go get her some water. You stay here with her." Atlas said.

He threw on a pair of shorts and a T-shirt before rushing out of the room. Oliver came over to me, and crawled in bed with me. As soon as he laid down I moved to straddle him. Oliver chuckled. "I thought I told you water first."

"You're not Leo." I said.

Oliver grabbed my hips. "I guess you're right."

"I want you to fuck me while I'm full of Atlas's cum. I can still feel yours dipping out of me. I like it. Is that weird?" I asked.

Oliver shook his head. "Not at all. You gonna ride me like you did Atlas? You were going all crazy, it was f*****g hot."

I giggled. "You think so?"

Oliver nodded. "Oh yeah."

I slid myself down on Oliver. Thank god he is still hard. My eyes rolled back once I had all of him inside of me. Oliver grabbed my hips, and rocked me on him.

"Fuck. You feel so fucking good. Better than anything I've ever felt." He said.

I started to more myself faster. "Really?" I asked.

Oliver nodded. "I could fuck you all day. You're p***y put a spell on me baby. You're ours forever." He told me. I moved faster and faster with every word. "Oh, so you like to be praised do you? Leo is gonna have fun with that." It feels so fucking good. Having Oliver inside of me while I'm already filled up with their cum. The only thing missing are the others.

"Do you think we could get Leo and Milo up here?" I asked.

Oliver chuckled. "Don't think I don't know that they put you up to this."

"Put her up to what?"

Oliver and I turned to see Atlas in the doorway. I froze. Oliver didn't care though, he just kept rocking my hips on him. It feels too f*****g good.

"Put her up to fucking you." Oliver said.

Atlas walked over to me. Oliver is still having me fuck him. My boobs are bouncing everywhere, and Atlas can't stop staring at them.

"That true babygirl?" Atlas asked.

"I.. They.. Oh my god.." I moaned out. Oliver has no care about the conversation. He just keeps bouncing me on top of him, making it hard to focus on anything. "They told me about the bet." I rushed out.

Atlas raised a brow at me. "And they had you set all this up so I'd lose huh?" He asked.

I bit my bottom lip and moaned. "I... Leo told me I didn't have to do anything I didn't want to." I said.

Atlas gave me a smile. "But you did anyways."

I pouted. "They... They said that I couldn't have all of you until someone won." I pracitcally whined out.

"Well, looks like we just have to enjoy the rest of our night with you then. Since we already lost." Oliver said.

Atlas crawled on the bed behind me, and wrapped his arms around me. "Guess so."