Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 35

I woke up to the sound of birds chirping. A smile fell on my lips as I cuddled more into my pillow. My pillow is awfully hard, and warm. Wiggling back I was met with more hard warmth. Then it all came rushing back to me. Last night. The brownies. The guys. The things we did.

My eyes flew open to see Oliver sleeping peacefully. He's completely naked, just like me. My face heated as I recalled what happened last night. I can't believe myself. And I have no one to blame but me. I was like a little thirsty whore. Like Milinda... I shook my head. I can't believe myself. I literally threw myself at all of them and I didn't even care. There was not one thought in my head that whole time that said 'this is wrong' or 'get ahold of yourself'. No, instead I practically begged them to use me. And they did.

All of them.

How does that make sense? Why do they all want me like that? Doesn't it bother them to share me like that? Is this just some kind of fantasy they all had that I fullfilled and now they're going to ignore me? Why does that make me feel so upset? I wiggled back some more, wanting to get out of the bed. Only I was met with a hard wall of warm muscle. An arm wrapped around my waist and pulled me even closer.

"Go back to sleep princess. I'm not ready to get up yet." Leo ordered gruffly.

Despite myself, my heart soared. I remember him leaving us last night and me telling him he better be here in the morning. He came back for me and that had me feeling all kinds of fuzzy inside. I hated it.

Still, I decided to just stay still. Although, my body had grown tense. Leo let out a deep sigh behind me. I thought he was going to say something but then Oliver rolled over with a groan and pulled me to him. He kissed the top of my head. "Good morning angel." He said.

"Uhm, good morning." I replied awkwardly.

Oliver pulled back enough to look down at me with his face scrunched. "What's wrong?" He asked.

How did he know something was wrong?

"N-nothing." I said lamely.

Oliver gave me a worried look.

"Oliver, can you go so that Millie and I can get a little more sleep? Thanks." Leo said.

Oliver placed a soft kiss to my lips before getting out of bed. My face flushed at his kiss. I watched him throw on a pair of boxers and a pair of orange basketball shorts. Where did those come from?

Then Oliver left the room. Leaving just Leo and me. At first I was afraid to move. This must be where he tells me that last night was a mistake. Leo is the one in charge. Or maybe they want to see if I'll do this again? Would I?

Taking a deep breath I mustered up all of my courage and turned around to face Leo. I can do this. I can totally handle being told that last night was a huge mistake. Looking up into Leo's green eyes had me feeling weak though. I should have never done anything with any of them. How were we supposed to be friends after this? My heart hurts. I finally got some real friends, and I ruined it all because I can't control my libido.

"What are you thinking about?" Leo asked as he ran his fingers along my face. I don't think I've ever heard him sound so soft. Great, he really is about to break the bad news to me.

I grabbed his hand and removed it from my face. "Can you just get it over with already?" I asked. I wanted to sound strong but my voice came out quiet.

Leo furrowed his brow. "Get what over with?" He asked.

I rolled my eyes and scooted away from him. "You know. Telling me how last night was a mistake and how you guys got what you wanted." I stated venomously.

Leo let out a sound that sounded like a growl. He reached out to grab my waist under the blanket and pulled me back to him. I looked up to match his angry expression.

"What the fuck are you talking about?" He asked. When I didn't answer Leo huffed in annoyance. "Millie, do you really think that's what I was going to say? That last night meant nothing to any of us? That you were just something fun?" He's seething.

"It wasn't like I didn't embarrassingly throw myself at all of you." I said as I crossed my arms. "I feel so stupid." I mumbled.

Leo unfolded my arms and wrapped one around his neck. He brought my other hand up to his lips and placed a soft kiss to my palm. Leo never broke eye contact with me and I could feel my cheeks heat up.

"Did you throw yourself at all of us? Yes." He said and my heart panged. "Was it the best night of our lives, for all of us? Also, yes." He said and I gave him a confused look.

"How.. How can you say that?" I asked.

Leo sighed. "I know it doesn't make sense to you right now Millie, but we all enjoyed last night. A lot. I've told you before, you are ours now. We all want you. We all wanted you last night, and this morning, and pretty much every second of every day." He said and all I could do was blink at him. "I am not telling you that last night was a mistake, because it wasn't. And we are not leaving you alone. We are going to do that again, eventually." He said with a smirk.

My face heated. I opened and closed my mouth a couple of times, trying to figure out what to say. "Really?" I squeaked out.

"I know this is confusing for you princess, but we all want you. Espeically after last night." Leo said with another smirk. "I think that we should get you high more often." He said and then leaned down to press his lips to mine.

At first I was too stunned to kiss him back. They... all really want me? Still? I mean, again, I didn't have sex with any of them but surely they had their fill of me last night. Do they really want more?

"Leo." I said and looked up to meet his green eyes. "What is it you all want from me exactly? Is this just... just a s*x thing?" I asked nervously.

If this was a sex thing then fine. I could be in for that, possibly. I mean, last night was really fun, even if I did wake up feeling like a whore. But... if they want more.. I just.. I'm not sure. How could I be in a relationship with all of them? That just spells heartbreak. I don't think I could share them like they share me.

"What do you want it to be?" He asked me.

I shrugged and looked away. "I don't know. But I don't want to wake up feeling like a whore again." I said.

Leo grabbed my chin and forced my eyes back to his. "Why do you feel like a whore? Because you had four guys at once last night?" He asked.

"Obviously." I said snarkily.

Leo smiled evily at me. "That doesn't make you a whore. I thought we had been over this. There is nothing wrong with having more than one partner as long as they are all okay with it. Right?" He asked.

"I guess.." I said.

"So, you have no reason to keep punishing yourself. No one here thinks you're a whore. In fact, I'm pretty sure that we are all much more obsessed with you after last night. I know I am." He said as he pulled me closer.

I smiled. "You still didn't answer my question." I said. "What is all of this?" I asked gesturing between the two of us.

Leo sighed. "I want to tell you, but I think it's something that everyone should be here for. Maybe this weekend we can all go do something together." He suggested.

"Like a date?" I asked.

"Yes." Leo stated.

I pulled back to look at him. "All five of us?" I asked.

Leo nodded. "All five of us." He repeated.

Then Leo dipped his head down and pressed his lips to mine again. I kissed him back, I couldn't help it. It's that damn lip ring. Leo too over the kiss completely. He pushed my body with his until he's hovering above me and between my legs. Leo is naked as well. He pushed himself against me and I could feel his hard member. I shivered. "Well, hope I'm not interrupting anything." Came Atlas's voice.

Leo pulled away from me and sat up on the bed. Atlas waltzed into the room and over to me. He's wearing nothing but a pair of black basketball shorts. Atlas lifted the covers and crawled into the bed with us. His arms circled around me and he pulled me into him while crashing our lips together.

"Sleep well babygirl?" He asked.

"She slept like a rock and then woke up in a sour mood." Leo said as he got up from the bed.

I frowned at him and Atlas matched it. "What do you mean a sour mood?" He asked.

Leo rummaged through some drawers before pulling out a pair of red basketball shorts and pulling them up. "Ask her." He said and then leaned against the dresser and folded his arms.

Atlas turned to me. "Babygirl?" He asked. When I didn't say anything Atlas tried again. "You know you can tell me anything right?" He asked.

"I can?" I asked back.

"Tell him princess. Tell Atlas what you thought I was going to say to you this morning." Leo ordered.

I glared at him before turning to Atlas. "I thought he was going to tell me that last night was a mistake." I stated.

Atlas's eyes went wide and his hold on me tightened. "Like hell last night was a mistake." He said. "Last night was the best night of my life and I didn't even get to be inside of you, or taste you." He said.

"She woke up feeling like a whore or some dumb shit like that." Leo added.

I turned my glare back to him.

"Babygirl, you are not a whore." Atlas stated. I turned my head back to him. "Maybe a whore for us, but just for us." He said with that cocky lopsided grin. "All ours, only ours." Atlas's eyes started to travel down my naked body. "Let's do last night again and maybe you'll feel better." He offered.

I scoffed to hide the giggle but I don't think it worked.

"She needs to eat. Last night took too much out of her." Leo said.

Atlas pouted and untangled his body from mine. "He's right, you passed out pretty hard after all of that."

Leo handed me a folded pile of girls clothes. "These are Lila's, I got them from her last night. There is a bathroom through that door. Meet us upstairs when you're done." He said and then kissed my forehead.

Atlas came over and kissed my lips before they both left me alone. Sighing I went to the bathroom and looked myself over in the mirror. I look the same. What was I expecting? To look different? I rolled my eyes at myself and got dressed. They even put an unopened toothbrush in here for me.

After I was done I looked myself over in the mirror again. The clothes Leo gave me are just a pajama set. A light purple pair of silk shorts and a matching button down silk top. My hair is still a mess and I wish that Leo would have left me a brush. After running my fingers through my hair I decided to head upstairs.

Caleb and Lila are sitting at the table acting all lovey. Lila is only in my brothers shirt and I had to try not to gag over it. Oliver and Leo are at the table with them talking. Atlas is in the kitchen getting a plate together. "Have a seat babygirl. I got a plate for you." Atlas said.

I beamed at him and took a seat between Oliver and Leo. "Where is Milo?" I asked.

Just then I could see Milo coming up the back steps with a surfboard under his arm. He set it down and then walked into the house. Our eyes connected immediately and he came over and placed a kiss to my lips. "Good morning cupcake." He said.

"G-good morning." I stuttered out as I peaked a glance at my brother, who didn't seem to notice.

"He knows." Oliver whispered to me.

I turned to him. "What?" I asked.

"Not all the details but he knows some." Leo said.

I wanted to question more but then Milo pulled up another chair between Oliver and me. "Cupcake, have you ever been surfing?"