Betrayed By Everyone, Loved By Four
Betrayed By Everyone Loved by Four Chapter 28

I placed myself how Leo had told me but facing the open room instead of the pillows. Just as I took in a deep breath Atlas's bathroom door opened up. Some steam pooled out and then out he walked. My lips parted as I raked my eyes along Atlas's body. He's only in My eyes were glued to his broad chest. He has his nipples pierced. Do they all have piercings? That's kind of hot, I mean, that's really hot.

a towel, that is hanging low, and dripping wet. It's like he didn't even bother to dry off.

Atlas walked a few more steps into the room and finally turned to look at me. His eyes went wide as they raked over my body. Atlas turned his body to face me and slowly closed the distance between us. He reached down and cupped my cheek. I stared up at him with the same look Leo ordered me to give.

"Holy f**k Millie." Atlas breathed out. "Did you take all of your clothes off?" He asked.

"No, I still have your jersey on." I told him sweetly.

Atlas blew out a shaky breath. "Fuck babygirl, this is the best surprise I think I've ever gotten." He told me.

I leaned into his palm. "You deserve it ya know." I told him as leaned up and placed my hands on his bare chest. God, he's warm.

"I do?" He asked.

I nodded my head and bit my bottom lip. "I have a confession to make Atlas." I told him as my fingers trailed across his body. Atlas was not joking when he told me there is nothing noodle-like about him. "I avoided all of you today on purpose. I was such a naughty girl Atlas." I said with a sweet voice and really put on a good pout at the end. Atlas's thumb trailed across my bottom lip that is sticking out. "I want to make it up to you." I told him.

"Babygirl, you don't have to make anything up-" He started but then I ripped his towel from his body stopping him.

My eyes went wide as I took in his length, and width. Holy shit, he's huge. I've only ever had experience with James, and James is not this big. Excitement is rolling throught me as I stared at Atlas's hard cock. One thing I did learn about myself, thanks to James, I have no gag reflex.

I looked up at Atlas through my lashes. He's just staring down at me but the lust in his eyes is clear. I made my eyes wider and slowly trailed my hands up his thighs to wrap around his c**k. Atlas hissed out in pleassure.

"I want to make you feel good." I told him and then flicked out my tongue and licked his head.

Atlas's body shuttered. "Wait, can I..." He trailed off and shook his head. "No, I won't ask that yet." He said.

"If you were going to ask to record it you have to." I told him softly.

"I.. have to.. oh fuck." He said before turning to grab his phone. I watched as Atlas fiddled with it before facing the camera down at me. "Thank you Leo." He mumbled.

I furrowed my brow. How does he know Leo ordered that? Whatever, I'd ask later. Right now I'm busy. I wrapped my hand back around Atlas's shaft. This time I wrapped my lips around his head. Atlas and I let out a moan at the same time. I can taste the precum on the tip of his head and it tastes so good. Salty, but yummy. It only fueled me on.

Atlas tangled his free hand in my hair pulling it out of my face. I stared up at him through my lashes, making sure to keep that wide eyed look he likes so much. Atlas shuttered and I could feel it run through his body. Without breaking eye contact I moved all the way down his long shaft. My mouth was having a hard time taking in the width of him. I can feel my throat close around his shaft.

"Holy fuck babygirl." Atlas breathed out. "You don't have a gag reflex?" He asked. I tried to shake my head around his c**k. "Oh f**k, that's f*****g great." He said breathlessly.

I rested my hands on Atlas's thighs as I started to bob my head up and down. My eyes stayed up on Atlas and his stupid phone while I worked his shaft. Atlas has his head rolled back. Small moans are leaving his sexy lips. There is something empowering about doing this with Atlas. He's such a big guy, to get reactions out of him like this is fun.

"Fuck babygirl this feels fucking amazing." He told me.

I moaned around his cock and started to move faster. Atlas gripped my hair tighter. His moans grew as I cupped and massaged his balls. Then I pulled away from him completely. "Atlas.." I whispered out and he looked down at me. "Show me how you like it." I told him before putting his head back in my mouth.

I waited for Atlas to take the reigns. Honestly, I barely know what I'm doing. I was hoping he really could show me how he likes it. Atlas muttered and moaned. He gripped my head and shoved me all the way down until my nose touched his skin. Atlas moaned as my throat constricted around him. Then he yanked me by my hair and pulled me away, then back again.

At this point Atlas is just using my mouth to fuck himself, and I am so for it. Giving head has never been his hot to me. I'm still holding onto his thigh with one hand and massaging his balls with the other. Atlas is growing rougher and rougher. Nothing but moans are coming from the two of us. My eyes rolled back as he continuously used me for his plessure. God, this is so hot. I'm so wet that I'm sure there's going to be a mark on his bed.

"Baby I'm so close. If you don't want to swallow my cum then tell me now." Atlas said.

I wrapped both of my arms around his thighs and pulled him closer. Atlas groaned and continued fucking my face. His moans are growing louder. Then I felt his hot seed spill into my mouth. Atlas groaned out as his movements slowed. I continued to suck on him as I swallowed everything he gave me. It's like I can't get enough. Atlas had stopped and here I am, still trying to suck out every last drop.

"Baby there's no more." Atlas said as his body shuttered.

I pulled away with a shy smile and wiped my mouth. "But you taste so good." I said.

Atlas tossed his phone to the side and gently pushed me until I was on my back. "Let me taste you now." He told me as he hovered above me.

I sat up before he could go where he was wanting to. "No." I said.

"Why not?" Atlas asked pouting.

I pouted with him. "Leo said no. This was about you not me." I stated grumpily.

Atlas chuckled. "I can't make you cum at all?" He asked. I shook my head. "What did you do to deserve this punishment babygirl?" Atlas asked amused.

I crossed my arms and huffed. "I told you I was a naughty girl today."

Atlas chuckled again and cupped my cheek. He sat down on the bed next to me and gave me his full attention. I snuggled in closer to him. Yeah, I'm sulking. That was the hottest thing I've ever done and now I get to be all bothered for the rest of the night. "What happened today babygirl? Talk to me." Atlas said softly.

I stared into his bright blue eyes. "I, uhm.." I trailed off as I looked away.

Atlas cupped my cheek and brought my eyes back to his. "Tell me." He pushed gently.

I took a deep breath. "Milinda made some comments about me wearing your jersey this morning, and, uhm, my brain just ran away with thoughts." I said vaguely. "Thoughts?" Atlas asked.

I nodded. "I just.. I just don't understand any of you. You all give me attention, flirt with me, none of you seem to care about... sharing me. It's almsot like it's fun for you. That alone is confusing enough. But.." I trailed off and took another deep breath. "I just thought that it made sense that you all were doing this with other girls too." I admitted.

"What?" Atlas asked as he shook his head.

"It makes sense. Why would you all just compete over me, or whatever it is you're all doing, and just me? There has to be other girls. And how could I even be mad at that when I have all of you? But still it hurt my feelings. As selfish as it sounds. I don't like the thought of any of you with someone else. And I can't be that way while I'm... doing stuff with all of you." I rambled.

At this point I feel like I'm talking more to myself. This is the first time I've voiced anything out loud. My only other friend is Lila and she seemed just as crazy as the rest of them when I talked to her.

"Millie look at me." Atlas ordered softly. I turned my head to meet his soft bright eyes. "I know it's confusing right now, and strange. But there is no one else that any of us are talking to. I promise you that you are the only one we want." He told me.

I nodded. "I believe you. And it is strange." I said. "I, uh, heard what you said to Milinda in the hallway right before last period." I admitted. "Leo and me. That's why he is punishing me. Because I let my thoughts overrun me instead of talking to you guys about it. Then he helped me with this." I said as I gestured between the two of us. "Hearing you turn down Milinda, and twice, was really hot and it made me really happy. So, I wanted to make you feel happy too." I told him with a smile.

Atlas grabbed me and pulled me into his lap. I'm straddling him now. I can feel his cock twitch against my bare pussy. I couldn't help it when I spread my legs more to place myself right on top of him. Atlas's eyes rolled back and he gripped my thighs. "Okay, keep that up and we will both feel Leo's rath." He told me.

I bit my bottom lip. "Would it really be that bad?" I asked and then ground myself on his now hard cock.

"Fuck babygirl." Atlas moaned out. "Yes, I promise you it would be very bad. He'd probably not let us touch each other for a week." He told me.

I had to think about that for a moment. Would Leo really do that? Yes. Would we really obey him? Also, yes. Leo just has that way about him. Or maybe I really am just a whore.

"Okay." I finally said and then lifted up so that our privates weren't touching anymore. I did, however, run my hands along his bare body. "I didn't know you had your nipples pierced." I told him.

Atlas chuckled. "We all got a piercing. It was a stupid pact we made when we were 16." He told me.

"You all got your nipples pierced?" I asked.

Atlas shook his head. "No, just me. Oliver got his ears, Leo got his lip, and Milo got his tongue, which I know you know about." He told me with a wink.

I blushed. "Yeah I remember." It was only a few days ago afterall.

"Yeah I bet you do." He said with a teasing tone.

"Shut up." I said as I slapped his bare chest.

Atlas chuckled and kissed my head. "You want to get dressed and go see our friends now? Maybe Leo will let you c*m tonight if you're a good girl." He told me. I got off of his lap and started gathering my clothes. "I doubt it." I mumbled.